The version of you that shows up at the leadership table

Belonging, imposter syndrome, and adapting yourself costs you

Why were you invited into the room?

A few years into my executive career, I sat at the leadership table and looked around the room.

Everyone there had more experience than me. Their agendas were different from mine, their attitude to life was different, and they approached things from a perspective I didn’t share. Even our core beliefs were different.

I didn’t feel like I belonged, and I’d already decided why I’d been invited. I believed I was there because I was a young woman.

I recognise the privilege in that now. Many of the people I work with have far more than age and gender working against them. But at the time, that belief shaped how I showed up. Some days I said everything I thought and challenged the room. Other days I held back.

I’m a very introspective person and in my own world inside my head, it was instantly obvious to me that I didn’t fit in. Instead of reflecting on what opportunities my differences (perceived or real) opened up for me and the room, I did what most people do when they look around and recognise that they don’t belong.

I adapted myself to fit.

Fast forward several years and the best advice I’ve been given about belonging is to stop thinking about it: feel like an imposter, and do it anyway.

It’s sound advice. It also came from someone who had never really had to question whether they belonged in the room based on traits that couldn’t be changed, and I’ve come to think that matters more than we admit.

When you don’t belong in a room, yet, belonging depends on the people in it accepting you. It becomes a question of fitting in, of being liked, and of learning what is required of you in that room.

So we do what capable people do. We adapt ourselves, we quiet ourselves where we need to, and we change ourselves to fit the room. I did it, and I see it in almost every leader I coach.

A few years after that first executive role, I asked for 360 feedback from people I’d worked with. The people who knew me best told me and who I’d worked with on large projects said that when I’m at my best, I challenge things and think differently from the rest of the room. They also told me they could tell when I was holding back, and it was usually at the executive table.

I recognised something - and I see it now in the clients that I coach - when you feel like you don’t belong in a room because of a trait you cannot change, like your gender, the colour of your skin, or your accent because your native language differs from the room’s, you adapt. But the issue is that you can’t change that trait, so you change what you can control.

Adaptability matters in our careers and in life. We need to adapt to the people around us, to the context and to the situation. But when we adapt who we are and what we bring, we are attempting to create sameness, and sameness is rarely why anyone gets invited into a room. We’re usually invited because we offer a different perspective.

Belonging and worth are closely tied.

Think about that one. How core is self-worth to our lives, to what we are capable of, what we believe about ourselves, whether we push for what we really want or not?

They are core beliefs about ourselves. They run deep, and the patterns repeat until we notice them. When you don’t feel you belong, it’s easy to decide that what you bring is worth less than what everyone else brings. So you hold it back, and the room loses the very reason you’re there.

When I coach leaders stepping into a new room (by now you may have noticed I use physical and figurative rooms interchangeably), whether that’s a bigger role, an executive team or a board, I start with three questions.

Question one: Why were you invited into this room? Something about you, your experience or your perspective made someone want you there. Get clear on what it is.

Question two: What do you offer that room today? Name it plainly, because it’s the thing you’ll be most tempted to hold back.

Question three: What’s the gap between what you offer today and where you need to be? That’s usually the stuff on paper: the experience, the knowledge and the track record the role asks for. That part you can build with time.

Then prepare.

Research the hell out of what’s being discussed, go in prepared, and launch in. Confidence comes last, after experience and mastery, so don’t wait for it before you speak.

Curiosity and staying humble are of course important; you don’t belong there - yet. You need to learn from others first. And after all - every one of those people around you who seem so confident and knowledgeable - had a first time too. A time when they had to learn from someone else, feel imposter syndrome, and speak up to earn their place for good.

But if there is one thing I’ve learnt, it’s this - in every room you are in, you must offer something.

Some differences will never change. Your skin colour, your accent or your background will still be in the room with you, and I’d never tell you to ignore them. But the difference is real, and the feeling can shift. As your experience and confidence grow, people start to notice what you bring before they notice how you’re different. And your differences, and your ways of thinking, are likely the things that will keep you in the room and make people talk about your value when you’re not there.

You won’t feel ready for the rooms that matter most in your career. You might be there because of your potential, or even a bit of luck. You don’t belong there yet, and that’s exactly why you were invited.

So which room are you holding back in right now?

If you’d like a clearer picture of the strengths you bring into the room, the Leadership Strengths Profile is a good place to start.

It takes 5 minutes, and when you’re done you can book a 30 minute call to talk through your results and what they mean for your leadership.

Next
Next

When High Performance Cultures Create Psychosocial Hazards